The Best Doctor Who Episode of All Time (2020)

It’s 2020, and this year has already brought us a whole new set of  Doctor Who adventures. As Series 12 has recently left our screens, now is as good a time as any to reflect on every official TV episode broadcast to date. I have watched the entire history of Doctor Who many times since I was a kid. For years, I have tried to determine, in my head, which is the best Doctor Who story ever made… my personal absolute favourite. It has been a hard task ranking all of the 295 stories (spread over 861 episodes) of Doctor Who that there have been over the past 57 years. But finally, I did manage to whittle it down to a definitive list, presented in the style of the polls conducted by Doctor Who Magazine. Please remember that this list is based purely on my own opinion as a hardcore Doctor Who fan.

Re-examining the episodes in this list has presented a few revelations to me. Like many other popular British TV shows, Doctor Who can be quite formulaic and repetitive – even for a programme that is partly meant for children. The same thing tends to happen in every episode. This seems surprising given that the central character can travel anywhere in time and space and can do almost anything. However, this does not lessen the fact that there are some episodes of Doctor Who that simply stand out from all the rest.

After this list, I have also included a personal ranking of other episodes from Doctor Who spin-offs and other media, such as Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures. So without further ado, let me reveal what I consider to be the ultimate ranking of every episode of Doctor Who.

Full Episode Ranking:

This ranking list is roughly divided into eight categories: Elite; Classics, Great, Good, OK, Below Average, Bad and Awful.

28ea976affc4bc886d7d8c552f2b78bb

Elite    

Rank Story Title Doctor Companion Classic Season / New Series Writer Year Foe
1.    The Caves of Androzani Fifth Doctor Peri Brown Season 21 Robert Holmes 1984 Sharaz Jek
2. Blink Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Series 3 Steven Moffat 2007 Weeping Angels
3. The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler, Captain Jack Harkness Series 1 Steven Moffat 2005 Nanogenes
4. Genesis of the Daleks Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, Harry Sullivan Season 12 Terry Nation 1975 Daleks, Davros
5. Midnight Tenth Doctor Donna Noble Series 4 Russell T Davies 2008 Midnight Entity
6. The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler Series 2 Matt Jones 2006 The Beast, Ood
7. The Talons of Weng-Chiang Fourth Doctor Leela Season 14 Robert Holmes 1977 Magnus Greel, Mr Sin
8. The Day of the Doctor War DoctorTenth Doctor

Eleventh Doctor

Clara Oswald, U.N.I.T 50th Anniversary Special Steven Moffat 2013 Zygons, Daleks
9. The Tomb of the Cybermen Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Victoria Waterfield Season 5 Kit Pedler & Gerry Davis 1967 Cybermen
10. Dalek Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler, Adam Mitchell Series 1 Robert Shearman 2005 Daleks

waters-main

Classics 

★★★

11. Heaven Sent Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 9 Steven Moffat 2015 The Veil
12. Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler, Captain Jack Harkness Series 1 Russell T Davies 2005 Daleks, Dalek Emperor
13. The Deadly Assassin Fourth Doctor Season 14 Robert Holmes 1976 The Master
14. The Five Doctors First DoctorSecond Doctor

Third Doctor

Fourth Doctor

Fifth Doctor

Tegan Jovanka, Vislor Turlough, Susan Foreman, The Brigadier, Sarah-Jane Smith, Romana, K-9 Mark III 20th Anniversary Special Terrance Dicks 1983 Rassilon, Borusa, Daleks, Cybermen, The Master, Yeti, Raston Warrior Robot
15. Terror of the Zygons Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, Harry Sullivan, U.N.I.T Season 13 Robert Banks Stewart 1975 Zygons
16. The Evil of the Daleks Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Victoria Waterfield Season 4 David Whitaker 1967 Daleks, Dalek Emperor
17. City of Death Fourth Doctor Romana Season 17 David Agnew 1979 Scaroth
18. World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Steven Moffat 2017 Cybermen, Missy, The Master
19. The Waters of Mars Tenth Doctor Captain Adelaide Brooke 2009 Specials Russell T Davies & Phil Ford 2009 The Flood
20. The Stolen Earth/Journey’s End Tenth Doctor Donna Noble, Martha Jones, Rose Tyler, Captain Jack Harkness, Sarah-Jane Smith, U.N.I.T Series 4 Russell T Davies 2008 Daleks, Davros
21. Human Nature/The Family of Blood Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Series 3 Paul Cornell 2007 The Family of Blood, Scarecrows
22. The Daleks’ Master Plan First Doctor Steven Taylor, Katarina, Sara Kingdom Season 3 Terry Nation & Dennis Spooner 1965-6 Daleks, Mavic Chen
23. Earthshock Fifth Doctor Adric, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 19 Eric Saward 1982 Cybermen
24. The Robots of Death Fourth Doctor Leela Season 14 Chris Boucher 1977 Voc Robots
25. Vincent and the Doctor Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond Series 5 Richard Curtis 2010 Krafayis
26. The Brain of Morbius Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 13 Robin Bland 1976 Morbius, The Sisterhood of Karn
27. The Tenth Planet First Doctor Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 Kit Pedler & Gerry Davis 1966 Cybermen
28. Spearhead from Space Third Doctor Liz Shaw, U.N.I.T Season 7 Robert Holmes 1970 Autons, Nestene Consciousness
29. Inferno Third Doctor Liz Shaw, U.N.I.T Season 7 Don Houghton 1970 Primords
30. Army of Ghosts/Doomsday Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler Series 2 Russell T Davies 2006 Daleks, Cybermen
31. The Silurians Third Doctor Liz Shaw, U.N.I.T Season 7 Malcolm Hulke 1970 Silurians
32. Turn Left Tenth Doctor Donna Noble, Rose Tyler, U.N.I.T Series 4 Russell T Davies 2008 Trickster’s Brigade
33. The Power of the Daleks Second Doctor Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 David Whitaker 1966 Daleks
34. Utopia/The Sound of Drums/Last of the Time Lords Tenth Doctor Martha Jones, Captain Jack Harkness, U.N.I.T Series 3 Russell T Davies 2007 The Master, Toclafane
35. Remembrance of the Daleks Seventh Doctor Ace Season 25 Ben Aaronovitch 1988 Daleks, Davros
36. The Invasion Second Doctor  Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot, U.N.I.T Season 6 Derrick Sherwin 1968 Cybermen
37. The Seeds of Doom Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 13 Robert Banks Stewart 1976 Krynoids
38. The Eleventh Hour Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond Series 5 Steven Moffat 2010 Prisoner Zero
39. School Reunion Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler, Mickey Smith, Sarah-Jane Smith, K-9 Mark III Series 2 Toby Whithouse 2006 Krillitanes
40. Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead Tenth Doctor Donna Noble, River Song Series 4 Steven Moffat 2008 Vashta Nerada
41. The Ark in Space Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, Harry Sullivan Season 12 Robert Holmes 1975 The Wirrn
42. Mummy on the Orient Express Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 8 Jamie Mathieson 2014 The Foretold
43. Cold War Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald Series 7 Mark Gatiss 2013 Ice Warriors
44. The Name of the Doctor Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald, River Song, The Paternoster Gang Series 7 Steven Moffat 2013 The Great Intelligence, Whispermen
45. The Three Doctors Third Doctor Jo Grant, U.N.I.T Season 10 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1972-3 Omega
_ The Night of the Doctor Eighth Doctor Cass 50th Anniversary Steven Moffat 2013 The Sisterhood of Karn
46. The War Games Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot Season 6 Terrance Dicks, Malcolm Hulke 1969 The Time Lords, War Lord, War Chief
47. The Zygon Invasion/The Zygon Inversion Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, U.N.I.T Series 9 Peter Harness & Steven Moffat 2015 Zygons
48. The Magician’s Apprentice/The Witch’s Familiar Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, U.N.I.T Series 9 Steven Moffat 2015 Daleks, Davros, The Master (Missy)
49. Dark Water/Death in Heaven Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, U.N.I.T Series 8 Steven Moffat 2014 The Master (Missy), Cybermen
50. Spyfall Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 12 Chris Chibnall 2020 The Master, Kasaavin, Daniel Barton
51. The Doctor’s Wife Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 6 Neil Gaiman 2011 House
52. The Green Death Third Doctor Jo Grant, U.N.I.T Season 10 Robert Sloman 1973 B.O.S.S, Giant Maggots
53. The Curse of Fenric Seventh Doctor Ace Season 26 Ian Briggs 1989 Fenric, Haemovores
54. Fugitive of the Judoon Thirteenth DoctorFugitive Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan, Captain Jack Harkness Series 12 Vinay Patel & Chris Chibnall 2020 Judoon, Gat
55. The Web of Fear Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Victoria Waterfield, Colonel Lethbridge-Stewart Season 5 Mervyn Haisman & Henry Lincoln 1968 Yeti, The Great Intelligence
56. The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams, River Song Series 6 Steven Moffat 2011 The Silence
57. Fury from the Deep Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Victoria Waterfield Season 5 Victor Pemberton 1968 Seaweed Creature
58. The Haunting of Villa Diodati Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 12 Maxine Alderton 2020 Cybermen
59. The Dalek Invasion of Earth First Doctor Susan Foreman, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 1 Terry Nation 1964 Daleks
60. Listen Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 8 Steven Moffat 2014
61. Pyramids of Mars Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 13 Stephen Harris 1976 Sutekh, Mummies
62. Marco Polo First Doctor Susan Foreman, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 1 John Lucarotti 1964 Tegana
_ Time Crash Tenth DoctorFifth Doctor Children in Need Special Steven Moffat 2007
63. The Dæmons  Third Doctor Jo Grant, U.N.I.T Season 8 Guy Leopold 1971 The Master, Azal, Bok
64. Flatline Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, Rigsy Series 8 Jamie Mathieson 2014 The Boneless
65. Father’s Day Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler Series 1 Paul Cornell 2005 Reapers

p00vd704

Great

★★★★☆ 

66. Carnival of Monsters Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 10 Robert Holmes 1973 Drashigs
67. Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler, Mickey Smith Series 2 Tom MacRae 2006 Cybermen
68. The Bells of Saint John Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald Series 7 Steven Moffat 2013 The Great Intelligence
69. The Girl in the Fireplace Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler, Mickey Smith Series 2 Steven Moffat 2006 Clockwork Robots
70. The Time Warrior Third Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 11 Robert Holmes 1973-4 Sontarans
71. The Sontaran Stratagem/The Poison Sky Tenth Doctor  Donna Noble, Martha Jones, U.N.I.T Series 4 Helen Raynor 2008 Sontarans
72. The Happiness Patrol Seventh Doctor Ace Season 25 Graeme Curry 1988 The Kandyman, Helen A
73. Under the Lake/Before the Flood Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 9 Toby Whithouse 2015 The Fisher King
74. Deep Breath Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, The Paternoster Gang Series 8 Steven Moffat 2014 Clockwork Robots
75. The Snowmen Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald, The Paternoster Gang Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2012 The Great Intelligence
76. The Androids of Tara Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 16 David Fisher 1978 Count Grendel
77. Amy’s Choice Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 5 Simon Nye 2010 The Dream Lord
78. The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, River Song Series 5 Steven Moffat 2010 Weeping Angels
79. Knock Knock Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Mike Bartlett 2017 The Landlord
80. The Pirate Planet Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 16 Douglas Adams 1978 The Captain, Xanxia
81. The War Machines First Doctor Dodo Chaplet, Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 3 Ian Stuart Black 1966 W.O.T.A.N, The War Machines
82. Into the Dalek Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 8 Phil Ford & Steven Moffat 2014 Daleks
83. The Sea Devils Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 9 Malcolm Hulke 1972 Sea Devils
84. The End of Time Tenth Doctor Wilfred Mott Christmas Special Russell T Davies 2009-10 The Master, Rassilon
85. The Chase First Doctor Vicki Pallister, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 2 Terry Nation 1965 Daleks, Mechanoids
86. The Enemy of the World Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Victoria Waterfield Season 5 David Whitaker 1967-8 Salamander
87. The Unicorn and the Wasp Tenth Doctor Donna Noble Series 4 Gareth Roberts 2008 Vespiform
88. The Time Meddler First Doctor Steven Taylor, Vicki Pallister Season 2 Dennis Spooner 1965 The Meddling Monk
89. The Stones of Blood Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 16 David Fisher 1978 Ogri, The Cessair of Diplos
90. The Angels Take Manhattan Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams, River Song Series 7 Steven Moffat 2012 Weeping Angels
91. The End of the World Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler Series 1 Russell T Davies 2005 Lady Cassandra
92. The Abominable Snowmen Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Victoria Waterfield Season 5 Mervyn Haisman & Henry Lincoln 1967 Yeti, The Great Intelligence
93. The Two Doctors Second DoctorSixth Doctor Peri Brown, Jamie McCrimmon Season 22 Robert Holmes 1985 Sontarans
94. The Lodger Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Craig Owens Series 5 Gareth Roberts 2010 79B Aickman Road
95. Mawdryn Undead Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka, The Brigadier Season 20 Peter Grimwade 1983 Mawdryn, The Black Guardian
96. The Curse of Peladon Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 9 Brian Hayles 1972 Ice Warriors, Arcturus, Hepesh
97. Snakedance Fifth Doctor Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 20 Christopher Bailey 1983 The Mara
98. Horror of Fang Rock Fourth Doctor Leela Season 15 Terrance Dicks 1977 Rutan Host
99. The Edge of Destruction First Doctor Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright, Susan Foreman Season 1 David Whitaker 1964
100. The Fires of Pompeii Tenth Doctor Donna Noble Series 4 James Moran 2008 Pyroviles
101. Vengeance on Varos Sixth Doctor Peri Brown Season 22 Philip Martin 1985 Sil
102. Enlightenment Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Tegan Jovanka Season 20 Barbara Clegg 1983 The Eternals, The Black Guardian
103. The Celestial Toymaker First Doctor Steven Taylor, Dodo Chaplet Season 3 Brian Hayles 1966 The Celestial Toymaker
104. A Good Man Goes to War Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams, River Song, The Paternoster Gang Series 6 Steven Moffat 2011 Madame Kovarian, Headless Monks
105. Frontier in Space Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 10 Malcolm Hulke 1973 The Master, Ogrons, Draconians, Daleks
106. The Christmas Invasion Tenth Doctor  Rose Tyler Christmas Special Russell T Davies 2005 Sycorax
107. The Visitation Fifth Doctor Adric, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 19 Eric Saward 1982 Terileptils
108. The Mind of Evil Third Doctor Jo Grant, U.N.I.T Season 8 Don Houghton 1971 The Master
109. The God Complex Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 6 Toby Whithouse 2011 Minotaur
110. Terror of the Autons Third Doctor Jo Grant, U.N.I.T Season 8 Robert Holmes 1972 The Master, Autons, Nestene Consciousness
111. The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams, River Song Series 5 Steven Moffat 2010 The Alliance
112. Day of the Daleks Third Doctor Jo Grant, U.N.I.T Season 9 Louis Marks 1972 Daleks, Ogrons
113. Planet of the Ood Tenth Doctor Donna Noble Series 4 Keith Temple 2008 Ood Operations
114. The Rescue First Doctor Vicki Pallister, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 2 David Whitaker 1965 Koquillion
115. Rosa Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Malorie Blackman & Chris Chibnall 2018 Krasko
116. The Romans First Doctor Vicki Pallister, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 2 Dennis Spooner 1965 Nero
117. Planet of Fire Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Peri Brown, Kamelion Season 21 Peter Grimwade 1984 The Master
118. Mission to the Unknown First Doctor Steven Taylor, Vicki Pallister Season 3 Dennis Spooner 1965 Daleks
119. The Face of Evil Fourth Doctor Leela Season 14 Chris Boucher 1977 Xoanon
120. The Aztecs First Doctor Susan Foreman, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 1 John Lucarotti 1964 Tlotoxl
121. The Unquiet Dead Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler Series 1 Mark Gatiss 2005 The Gelth
122. An Unearthly Child First Doctor Susan Foreman, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 1 Anthony Coburn 1963 Kal
123. The Girl Who Waited Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 6 Tom MacRae 2011 Handbots

p01gqpnh

Good 

★★★Untitled☆ 

124. The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 5 Chris Chibnall 2010 Silurians
125. The Shakespeare Code Tenth Doctor  Martha Jones Series 3 Gareth Roberts 2007 Carrionites
126. Tooth and Claw Tenth Doctor  Rose Tyler Series 2 Russell T Davies 2006 Werewolf
127. The Rebel Flesh/The Almost People Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 6 Matthew Graham 2011 Gangers
128. Rose Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler Series 1 Russell T Davies 2005 Autons, Nestene Consciousness
129. Paradise Towers Seventh Doctor Mel Bush Season 24 Stephen Wyatt 1987 Kroagnon
130. The Woman Who Fell to Earth Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Chris Chibnall 2018 Tzim-Sha
131. Robot Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, Harry Sullivan, U.N.I.T Season 12 Terrance Dicks 1974-5 Giant K-1 Robot
132. Hide Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald Series 7 Neil Cross 2013 The Crooked Man
133. The Leisure Hive Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 18 David Fisher 1980 The Foamasi
134. Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 12 Nina Métivier 2020 Skithra
135. The Pilot Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Steven Moffat 2017 Heather, Daleks, Movellans
136. Resolution Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan New Year’s Day Special Chris Chibnall 2019 Daleks
137. Kinda Fifth Doctor Adric, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 19 Christopher Bailey 1982 The Mara
138. The Crimson Horror Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald, The Paternoster Gang Series 7 Mark Gatiss 2013 Mr Sweet
139. The Sun Makers Fourth Doctor Leela, K-9 Mark I Season 15 Robert Holmes 1977 Usurians
140. Resurrection of the Daleks Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Tegan Jovanka Season 21 Eric Saward 1984 Daleks
141. State of Decay Fourth Doctor Romana, Adric, K-9 Mark II Season 18 Terrance Dicks 1980 Great Vampires
142. The Ark First Doctor Steven Taylor, Dodo Chaplet Season 3 Paul Erickson, Lesley Scott 1966 Monoids
143. Kerblam! Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Pete McTighe 2018 Charlie Duffy, Kerblam Men
144. The Vampires of Venice Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 5 Toby Whithouse 2010 Saturnyns
145. Planet of the Spiders Third Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, U.N.I.T Season 11 Robert Sloman 1974 Metebelis Spiders
146. Castrovalva Fifth Doctor Adric, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 19 Christopher H Bidmead 1982 The Master
147. Extremis Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Steven Moffat 2017 The Monks, The Master (Missy)
148. Oxygen Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Jamie Mathieson 2017 Ganymede Systems
149. The Witchfinders Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Joy Wilkinson 2018 Morax
150. The Woman Who Lived Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, Ashildr Series 9 Catherine Tregenna 2015 Leandro
151. Arachnids in the UK Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Chris Chibnall 2018 Giant Mutant Spiders, Jack Robertson
152. Dinosaurs on a Spaceship Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams, Brian Williams Series 7 Chris Chibnall 2012 Solomon
153. Boom Town Ninth Doctor Rose Tyler, Mickey Smith, Captain Jack Series 1 Russell T Davies 2005 Slitheen
154. The Ambassadors of Death Third Doctor Liz Shaw, U.N.I.T Season 7 David Whitaker 1970 General Carrington
155. Gridlock Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Series 3 Russell T Davies 2007 Macra
156. The Greatest Show in the Galaxy Seventh Doctor Ace Season 25 Stephen Wyatt 1988-9 Clowns, The Gods of Ragnarok
157. The Husbands of River Song Twelfth Doctor River Song, Nardole Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2015 King Hydroflax. The Shoal of the Winter Harmony
158. Survival Seventh Doctor Ace Season 26 Rona Munro 1989 The Master, Cheetah People
159. The Creature from the Pit Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 17 David Fisher 1979 Adrasta
160. The Macra Terror Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 Ian Stuart Black 1967 Macra
161. Thin Ice Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Sarah Dollard 2017 Robot Knights, Sheriff of Nottingham
162. A Town Called Mercy Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 7 Toby Whithouse 2012 Kahler-Jex
163. Image of the Fendahl Fourth Doctor Leela, K-9 Mark I Season 15 Chris Boucher 1977 Fendahl
164. Ghost Light Seventh Doctor Ace Season 26 Marc Platt 1989 Light
165. Logopolis Fourth Doctor Adric, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 18 Christopher H Bidmead 1981 The Master
166. Love & Monsters Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler, Elton Pope Series 2 Russell T Davies 2006 Absorbaloff
167. The Keeper of Traken Fourth Doctor Adric, Nyssa Season 18 Johnny Byrne 1981 The Master
168. The Myth Makers First Doctor Vicki Pallister, Steven Taylor, Katarina Season 3 Donald Cotton 1965 Cassandra
169. Doctor Who: The TV Movie Eighth Doctor Grace, Chang Lee The TV Movie Matthew Jacobs 1996 The Master
170. Planet of the Daleks Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 10 Terry Nation 1973 Daleks
171. Can You Hear Me? Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 12 Charlene James & Chris Chibnall 2020 Zellin, Rakaya
172. Face the Raven Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, Rigsy Series 9 Sarah Dollard 2015 Quantum Shade
173. Revelation of the Daleks Sixth Doctor Peri Brown Season 22 Eric Saward 1985 Daleks
174. The Crusade First Doctor Vicki Pallister, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 2 David Whitaker 1965 El Akir
175. The Hand of Fear Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 14 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1976 Eldrad
176. The Seeds of Death Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot Season 6 Brian Hayles 1969 Ice Warriors

World-War-Three-9th-Ninth-Christopher-Eccleston-Slitheen

OK

★★★☆☆

177. Aliens of London/World War Three Ninth Doctor  Rose Tyler Series 1 Russell T Davies 2005 Slitheen
178. Partners in Crime Tenth Doctor Donna Noble Series 4 Russell T Davies 2008 Miss Foster, Adipose
_ Shada Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 17 Douglas Adams 1980 Kraals, Skagra
179. Time Heist Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 8 Steve Thompson & Steven Moffat 2014 Madame Karabraxos
180. Battlefield Seventh Doctor Ace Season 26 Ben Aaronovitch 1989 Morgaine, The Destroyer
181. Frontios Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Tegan Jovanka Season 21 Christopher H Bidmead 1984 Tractators
182. Revenge of the Cybermen Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, Harry Sullivan Season 12 Gerry Davis 1975 Cybermen
183. The Krotons Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot Season 6 Robert Holmes 1968-9 Krotons
184. The Beast Below Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond Series 5 Steven Moffat 2010 Smilers
185. The Keys of Marinus First Doctor Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright, Susan Foreman Season 1 Terry Nation 1964 The Voord
186. Destiny of the Daleks Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 17 Terry Nation 1979 Daleks, Davros
187. Twice Upon a Time First DoctorTwelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2017 Glass Avatars
188. The Claws of Axos Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 8 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1971 The Master, Axons
189. The Wedding of River Song Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams, River Song Series 6 Steven Moffat 2011 Madame Kovarian
190. Ascension of the Cybermen/The Timeless Children Thirteenth DoctorFugitive Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 12 Chris Chibnall 2020 The Master, Cybermen
191. Full Circle Fourth Doctor Romana, Adric, K-9 Mark II Season 18 Andrew Smith 1980 Marshmen
192. The Sontaran Experiment Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, Harry Sullivan Season 12 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1975 Sontarans
193. The Lazarus Experiment Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Series 3 Stephen Thompson 2007 Professor Lazarus
194. Empress of Mars Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Mark Gatiss 2017 Ice Warriors, The Master (Missy)
195. Orphan 55 Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 12 Ed Hime 2020 Dregs
196. The Trial of a Time Lord Sixth Doctor Peri Brown, Mel Bush Season 23 Robert Holmes, Philip Martin, Pip & Jane Baker 1986 Drathro, Sil, Vervoids, The Valeyard, The Master
197. Last Christmas Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2014 The Kantrofarri
198. The Monster of Peladon Third Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 11 Brian Hayles 1974 Ice Warriors
199. Death to the Daleks Third Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 11 Terry Nation 1974 Daleks
200. The Mind Robber Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot Season 6 Peter Ling 1968 White Robots, The Master of the Land of Fiction
201. The Return of Doctor Mysterio Twelfth Doctor Nardole Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2016 The Shoal of the Winter Harmony
202. The Gunfighters  First Doctor Steven Taylor, Dodo Season 3 Donald Cotton 1966 Johnny Ringo, Clanton Brothers
203. Warriors’ Gate Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 18 Steve Gallagher 1981 Captain Rorvik
204. The Long Game Ninth Doctor Rose Tyler, Adam Mitchell Series 1 Russell T Davies 2005 Jagrafess
205. The Idiot’s Lantern Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler Series 2 Mark Gatiss 2006 The Wire
206. Planet of Evil Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 13 Louis Marks 1975 Anti-matter monsters
207. It Takes You Away Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Ed Hime 2018 Solitract, Ribbons
208. Planet of Giants First Doctor Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright, Susan Foreman Season 2 Louis Marks 1964 Forester
209. The Reign of Terror First Doctor Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright, Susan Foreman Season 1 Dennis Spooner 1964 Robespierre
210. The Caretaker Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 8 Gareth Roberts & Steven Moffat 2014 Skovox Blitzer
211. The Massacre First Doctor Steven Taylor, Dodo Chaplet Season 3 John Lucarotti & Donald Tosh 1966 Catherine de Medici
212. A Christmas Carol Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2010 Kazran Sardick
213. The Masque of Mandragora Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith Season 14 Louis Marks 1976 The Mandragora Helix

dragonfire

Below Average 

★★Untitled☆☆ 

214. Voyage of the Damned Tenth Doctor Astrid Peth Christmas Special Russell T Davies 2007 Max Capricorn, Heavenly Hosts
215. The Runaway Bride Tenth Doctor Donna Noble Christmas Special Russell T Davies 2006 Racnoss
216. Attack of the Cybermen Sixth Doctor Peri Brown Season 22 Paula Moore 1985 Cybermen
217. The King’s Demons Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Tegan Jovanka, Kamelion Season 20 Terence Dudley 1983 The Master
_ The Infinite Quest Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Animated Special Alan Barnes 2007 Balthazar
218. Invasion of the Dinosaurs Third Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, U.N.I.T Season 11 Malcolm Hulke 1974 Operation Golden Age
219. Black Orchid Fifth Doctor Adric, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 19 Terence Dudley 1982 George Cranleigh
220. The Doctor’s Daughter Tenth Doctor Donna Noble, Martha Jones, Jenny Series 4 Stephen Greenhorn 2008 The Hath
221. Dragonfire Seventh Doctor Mel Bush, Ace Season 24 Ian Briggs 1987 Kane
222. Arc of Infinity Fifth Doctor Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 20 Johnny Byrne 1983 Omega, The Ergon
223. The Ghost Monument Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Chris Chibnall 2018 Remnants
224. The Savages First Doctor Steven Taylor, Dodo Chaplet Season 3 Ian Stuart Black 1966 Captain Edal
225. The Time of the Doctor Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2013 The Silence, Daleks, Cybermen, Sontarans, Weeping Angels
226. The Moonbase Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 Kit Pedler 1967 Cybermen
227. Planet of the Dead Tenth Doctor Lady Christina de Souza Easter Special Gareth Roberts & Russell T Davies 2009 Stingrays
228. The Eaters of Light Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Rona Munro 2017 Eaters of Light, The Master (Missy)
229. The Wheel in Space Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot Season 5 David Whitaker 1968 Cybermen
230. 42 Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Series 3 Chris Chibnall 2007 Torajii Sun
231. The Armageddon Factor Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark I Season 16 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1979 The Black Guardian, The Shadow
232. The Faceless Ones Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 David Ellis & Malcolm Hulke 1967 Chameleons
234. Night Terrors Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 6 Mark Gatiss 2011 Peg Dolls
235. The Mark of the Rani Sixth Doctor Peri Brown Season 22 Pip & Jane Baker 1985 The Rani, The Master
236. The Ribos Operation Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 16 Robert Holmes 1978 Graff Vynda-K
237. The Girl Who Died Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, Ashildr Series 9 Jamie Mathieson & Steven Moffat 2015 Mire
238. The Awakening Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Tegan Jovanka Season 21 Eric Pringle 1984 The Malus
239. The Lie of the Land Twelfth Doctor  Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Toby Whithouse 2017 The Monks, The Master (Missy)
240. The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Chris Chibnall 2018 Tzim-Sha
241. The Mutants Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 9 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1972 The Marshall
242. Praxeus Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 12 Pete McTighe 2020 Praxeus
243. The Ice Warriors Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Victoria Waterfield Season 5 Brian Hayles 1967 Ice Warriors

the-invasion-of-time-1

Bad

★★☆☆☆ 

244. Victory of the Daleks Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond Series 5 Mark Gatiss 2010 Daleks
245. Smith and Jones Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Series 3 Russell T Davies 2007 Judoon, Plasmavore
246. The Android Invasion Fourth Doctor Sarah-Jane Smith, U.N.I.T Season 13 Terry Nation 1975 Kraals
247. Robot of Sherwood Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 8 Mark Gatiss 2014 Robot Knights, Sheriff of Nottingham
248. Four to Doomsday Fifth Doctor Adric, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 19 Terence Dudley 1982 Monarch
249. Nightmare in Silver Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald Series 7 Neil Gaiman 2013 Cybermen
250. The Power of Three Eleventh Doctor  Amy Pond, Rory Williams, Brian Williams, U.N.I.T Series 7 Chris Chibnall 2012 The Shakri
251. Kill the Moon Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald, Courtney Series 8 Peter Harness 2014 Moon bacteria spiders
252. Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald Series 7 Steve Thompson 2013 Time zombies
253. Closing Time Eleventh Doctor  Amy Pond, Rory Williams, Craig Owens Series 6 Gareth Roberts 2011 Cybermen
254. The Daleks First Doctor Susan Foreman, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 1 Terry Nation 1963-4 Daleks
255. The Highlanders Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 Elwyn Jones & Gerry Davis 1966 Grey, Trask
256. The Next Doctor Tenth Doctor Jackson Lake Christmas Special Russell T Davies 2008 Cybermen
257. The Invasion of Time Fourth Doctor Leela, K-9 Mark I Season 15 David Agnew 1978 Vardans, Sontarans
258. New Earth Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler Series 2 Russell T Davies 2006 Lady Cassandra, Sisters of Plenitude
259. Meglos Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 18 John Flanagan & Andrew McCulloch 1980 Meglos
260. Nightmare of Eden Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 17 Bob Baker 1979 Mandrels
261. The Rings of Akhaten Eleventh Doctor Clara Oswald Series 7 Neil Cross 2013 Akhaten, The Vigil, The Mummy
262. Colony in Space Third Doctor Jo Grant Season 8 Malcolm Hulke 1971 The Master
263. Hell Bent Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 9 Steven Moffat 2015 Rassilon, The Sisterhood of Karn
264. The Time Monster Third Doctor Jo Grant, U.N.I.T Season 9 Robert Sloman 1972 The Master
265. The Curse of the Black Spot Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 6 Stephen Thompson 2011 The Siren
266. Galaxy 4 First Doctor Steven Taylor, Vicki Pallister Season 3 William Emms 1965 Drahvins
267. Terminus Fifth Doctor Vislor Turlough, Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 20 Steve Gallagher 1983 Black Guardian, The Vanir
268. Demons of the Punjab Thirteenth Doctor  Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Vinay Patel 2018 Manish, Thijarians
269. Daleks in Manhattan/Evolution of the Daleks Tenth Doctor Martha Jones Series 3 Helen Raynor 2007 Daleks
270. The Sensorites First Doctor Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright, Susan Foreman Season 1 Peter R Newman 1964 City Administrator
271. The Pyramid at the End of the World Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts, Nardole Series 10 Peter Harness & Steven Moffat 2017 The Monks
272. The Power of Kroll Fourth Doctor Romana, K-9 Mark II Season 16 Robert Holmes 1978 Kroll
273. Asylum of the Daleks Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Series 7 Steven Moffat 2012 Daleks
274. Smile Twelfth Doctor Bill Potts Series 10 Frank Cottrell-Boyce 2017 Emoji Bots
275. The Invisible Enemy Fourth Doctor Leela & K-9 Mark I Season 15 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1977 The Nucleus of the Swarm
276. In the Forest of the Night Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 8 Frank Cottrell-Boyce 2014
277. The Smugglers First Doctor Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 Brian Hayles 1966 Samuel Pike
_ Dreamland Tenth Doctor Cassie, Jimmy Animated Special Phil Ford 2009 Lord Azlok, Viperox

WHO064_alt-770x408

Awful 

★☆☆☆☆

278. Warriors of the Deep Fifth Doctor Tegan Jovanka, Vislor Turlough Season 21 Johnny Byrne 1984 Silurians, Sea Devils
279. The Underwater Menace Second Doctor  Jamie McCrimmon, Ben Jackson, Polly Wright Season 4 Geoffrey Orme 1967 Professor Zaroff
280. Sleep No More Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald Series 9 Mark Gatiss 2015 Sandmen
281. Silver Nemesis Seventh Doctor Ace Season 25 Kevin Clarke 1988 Cybermen
282. Fear Her Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler Series 2 Matthew Graham 2006 Isolus
283. Time-Flight Fifth Doctor Nyssa, Tegan Jovanka Season 19 Peter Grimwade 1982 The Master
284. The Horns of Nimon Fourth Doctor Romana,     K-9 Mark II Season 17 Anthony Read 1979-80 Nimon
285. The Space Museum First Doctor Vicki Pallister, Ian Chesterton, Barbara Wright Season 2 Glyn Jones 1965 Moroks
286. Let’s Kill Hitler Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams, River Song Series 6 Steven Moffat 2011 Teselecta Anti-bodies
287. The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond, Rory Williams Christmas Special Steven Moffat 2011 Androzani Trees
288. Delta and the Bannermen Seventh Doctor Melanie Bush Season 24 Malcolm Kohll 1987 Gavrok, Bannermen
289. The Web Planet First Doctor  Barbara Wright,     Ian Chesterton, Vicki Season 2 Bill Strutton 1965 Zarbi,         The Animus
290. The Tsuranga Conundrum Thirteenth Doctor Graham O’Brien, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan Series 11 Chris Chibnall 2018 Pting
291. The Dominators Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot Season 6 Norman Ashby 1968 Quarks, Dominators
292. Timelash Sixth Doctor Peri Brown Season 22 Glen McCoy 1985 The Borad
293. Underworld   Fourth Doctor Leela Season 15 Bob Baker & Dave Martin 1978 The Oracle
294. The Twin Dilemma Sixth Doctor Peri Brown Season 21 Anthony Steven 1984 Mestor
295. The Space Pirates Second Doctor Jamie McCrimmon, Zoe Heriot Season 6 Robert Holmes 1969 Caven
296. Time and the Rani Seventh Doctor Mel Bush Season 24 Pip & Jane Baker 1987 The Rani, Tetraps

WHO050-770x513

But what do the fans think…

The table below shows how the Doctor Who fandom regards all of the television stories transmitted up to the present day. There are two columns, one for the 2014 Doctor Who Magazine poll and also one for a 2020 poll conducted on Twitter.

EXkHLc8XYAAnUDv

Here’s a chronological Doctor-by-Doctor breakdown of my own results, ranked on a category-by-category basis:

By Doctor:

Jo-Martin-Doctor-Who-1

R. The Fugitive Doctor (Jo Martin)* – 2020

  1. Fugitive of the Judoon – CLASSICS (#54)
  2. The Timeless Children – OK (#190)

first-doctor-william-hartnell

1. The First Doctor (William Hartnell) – 1963-1966

  1. The Daleks’ Master Plan – CLASSICS (#22)
  2. The Tenth Planet – CLASSICS (#27)
  3. The Dalek Invasion of Earth – CLASSICS (#59)
  4. Marco Polo – CLASSICS (#62)
  5. The War Machines – GREAT (#81)
  6. The Chase – GREAT (#85)
  7. The Time Meddler – GREAT (#88)
  8. The Edge of Destruction – GREAT (#99)
  9. The Celestial Toymaker – GREAT (#103)
  10. The Rescue – GREAT (#114)
  11. The Romans – GREAT (#116)
  12. Mission to the Unknown – GREAT (#118)
  13. The Aztecs – GREAT (#120)
  14. An Unearthly Child – GREAT (#122)
  15. The Ark – GOOD (#142)
  16. The Myth Makers – GOOD (#168)
  17. The Crusade – GOOD (#174)
  18. The Keys of Marinus – OK (#185)
  19. The Gunfighters – OK (#202)
  20. Planet of Giants – OK (#208)
  21. The Reign of Terror – OK (#209)
  22. The Massacre – OK (#211)
  23. The Savages – BELOW AVERAGE (#224)
  24. The Daleks – BAD (#254)
  25. Galaxy 4 – BAD (#266)
  26. The Sensorites – BAD (#270)
  27. The Smugglers – BAD (#277)
  28. The Space Museum – AWFUL (#285)
  29. The Web Planet – AWFUL (#289)

1st Doctor Tier List

patrick-troughton-second-doctor

 2. The Second Doctor (Patrick Troughton) – 1966-1969

  1. The Tomb of the Cybermen – ELITE (#9)
  2. The Evil of the Daleks – CLASSICS (#16)
  3. The Power of the Daleks – CLASSICS (#33)
  4. The Invasion – CLASSICS (#36)
  5. The War Games – CLASSICS (#46)
  6. The Web of Fear – CLASSICS (#55)
  7. Fury from the Deep – CLASSICS (#57)
  8. The Enemy of the World – GREAT (#86)
  9. The Abominable Snowmen – GREAT (#92)
  10. The Macra Terror – GOOD (#160)
  11. The Seeds of Death – GOOD (#176)
  12. The Krotons – OK (#183)
  13. The Mind Robber – OK (#200)
  14. The Moonbase – BELOW AVERAGE (#226)
  15. The Wheel in Space – BELOW AVERAGE (#229)
  16. The Faceless Ones – BELOW AVERAGE (#232)
  17. The Ice Warriors – BELOW AVERAGE (#243)
  18. The Highlanders – BAD (#255)
  19. The Underwater Menace – AWFUL (#279)
  20. The Dominators – AWFUL (#291)
  21. The Space Pirates – AWFUL (#295)

2nd Doctor Tier List

classic-doctor-who-jon-pertwee

 3. The Third Doctor (Jon Pertwee) – 1970-1974

  1. Spearhead from Space – CLASSICS (#28)
  2. Inferno – CLASSICS (#29)
  3. The Silurians – CLASSICS (#31)
  4. The Three Doctors – CLASSICS (#45)
  5. The Green Death – CLASSICS (#52)
  6. The Dæmons – CLASSICS (#63)
  7. Carnival of Monsters – GREAT (#66)
  8. The Time Warrior – GREAT (#70)
  9. The Sea Devils – GREAT (#83)
  10. The Curse of Peladon – GREAT (#96)
  11. Frontier in Space – GREAT (#105)
  12. The Mind of Evil – GREAT (#108)
  13. Terror of the Autons – GREAT (#110)
  14. Day of the Daleks – GREAT (#112)
  15. Planet of the Spiders – GOOD (#145)
  16. The Ambassadors of Death – GOOD (#154)
  17. Planet of the Daleks – GOOD (#170)
  18. The Claws of Axos – OK (#188)
  19. The Monster of Peladon – OK (#198)
  20. Death to the Daleks – OK (#199)
  21. Invasion of the Dinosaurs – BELOW AVERAGE  (#218)
  22. The Mutants – BELOW AVERAGE (#241)
  23. Colony in Space – BAD (#262)
  24. The Time Monster – BAD (#264)

3rd Doctor Tier List

fourth-doctor-scarf

 4. The Fourth Doctor (Tom Baker) – 1974-1981

  1. Genesis of the Daleks – ELITE (#4)
  2. The Talons of Weng-Chiang – ELITE (#7)
  3. The Deadly Assassin – CLASSICS (#13)
  4. Terror of the Zygons – CLASSICS (#15)
  5. City of Death – CLASSICS (#17)
  6. The Robots of Death – CLASSICS (#24)
  7. The Brain of Morbius – CLASSICS (#26)
  8. The Seeds of Doom – CLASSICS (#37)
  9. The Ark in Space – CLASSICS (#41)
  10. Pyramids of Mars – CLASSICS (#61)
  11. The Androids of Tara – GREAT (#76)
  12. The Pirate Planet – GREAT (#80)
  13. The Stones of Blood – GREAT (#89)
  14. Horror of Fang Rock – GREAT (#98)
  15. The Face of Evil – GREAT (#119)
  16. Robot – GOOD (#131)
  17. The Leisure Hive – GOOD (#133)
  18. The Sun Makers – GOOD (#139)
  19. State of Decay – GOOD (#141)
  20. The Creature from the Pit – GOOD (#159)
  21. Image of the Fendahl – GOOD (#163)
  22. Logopolis – GOOD (#165)
  23. The Keeper of Traken – GOOD (#167)
  24. The Hand of Fear – GOOD (#175) This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 230604-utopia-2023-1566.jpg
  25. Shada – OK
  26. Revenge of the Cybermen – OK (#182)
  27. Destiny of the Daleks – OK (#186)
  28. Full Circle – OK (#191)
  29. The Sontaran Experiment – OK (#192)
  30. Warriors’ Gate – OK (#203)
  31. Planet of Evil – OK (#206)
  32. The Masque of Mandragora – OK (#213)
  33. The Armageddon Factor – BELOW AVERAGE (#231)
  34. The Ribos Operation – BELOW AVERAGE (#236)
  35. The Android Invasion – BAD (#246)
  36. The Invasion of Time – BAD (#257)
  37. Meglos – BAD (#259)
  38. Nightmare of Eden – BAD (#260)
  39. The Power of Kroll – BAD (#272)
  40. The Invisible Enemy – BAD (#275)
  41. The Horns of Nimon – AWFUL (#284)
  42. Underworld – AWFUL (#293)

4th Doctor Tier List

Doctor-Who-Peter-Davison-Fifth-Doctor-600x337

 5. The Fifth Doctor (Peter Davison) – 1981-1984

  1. The Caves of Androzani – ELITE (#1)
  2. The Five Doctors – CLASSICS (#14)
  3. Earthshock – CLASSICS (#23)
  4. Mawdryn Undead – GREAT (#95)
  5. Snakedance – GREAT (#97)
  6. Enlightenment – GREAT (#102)
  7. The Visitation – GREAT (#107)
  8. Planet of Fire – GREAT (#117)
  9. Kinda – GOOD (#137)
  10. Resurrection of the Daleks – GOOD (#140)
  11. Castrovalva – GOOD (#146)
  12. Frontios – OK (#181)
  13. The King’s Demons – BELOW AVERAGE (#217)
  14. Black Orchid – BELOW AVERAGE (#219)
  15. Arc of Infinity – BELOW AVERAGE (#222)
  16. The Awakening – BELOW AVERAGE (#238)
  17. Four to Doomsday – BAD (#248)
  18. Terminus – BAD (#267)
  19. Warriors of the Deep – AWFUL (#278)
  20. Time-Flight – AWFUL (#283)

5th Doctor Tier List

sixth-doctor

 6. The Sixth Doctor (Colin Baker) – 1984-1986

  1. The Two Doctors – GREAT (#93)
  2. Vengeance on Varos – GREAT (#101)
  3. Revelation of the Daleks – GOOD (#173)
  4. The Trial of a Time Lord – OK (#196)
  5. Attack of the Cybermen – BELOW AVERAGE (#216)
  6. The Mark of the Rani – BELOW AVERAGE (#235)
  7. Timelash – AWFUL (#292)
  8. The Twin Dilemma – AWFUL (#294)

6th Doctor Tier List

9a986bd8ba4b3f58ca8a493d68dbd775

 7. The Seventh Doctor (Sylvester McCoy) – 1987-1989, 1996

  1. Remembrance of the Daleks – CLASSICS (#35)
  2. The Curse of Fenric – CLASSICS (#53)
  3. The Happiness Patrol – GREAT (#72)
  4. Paradise Towers – GOOD (#129)
  5. The Greatest Show in the Galaxy – GOOD (#156) This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 230602-utopia-2023-547.jpg This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is img_7491.jpg
  6. Survival – GOOD (#158)
  7. Ghost Light – GOOD (#164)
  8. Battlefield – OK (#180)
  9. Dragonfire – BELOW AVERAGE (#221)
  10. Silver Nemesis – AWFUL (#281)
  11. Delta and the Bannermen – AWFUL (#288)
  12. Time and the Rani – AWFUL (#296)

7th Doctor Tier List

afaaa-600x337

8. The Eighth Doctor (Paul McGann) – 1996, 2013

  1. The Night of the Doctor – CLASSICS
  2. Doctor Who: The TV Movie – GOOD (#169)

8th Doctor Tier List

anglo_1920x1080_wardoctor-1600x720

W. The War Doctor (John Hurt)* – 2013

  1. The Day of the Doctor – ELITE (#8)
  2. The Night of the Doctor – CLASSICS
  3. The Name of the Doctor – CLASSICS (#44)

eccleston-2-bbc-625x352

9. The Ninth Doctor (Christopher Eccleston) – 2005

  1. The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances – ELITE (#3)
  2. Dalek – ELITE (#10)
  3. Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways – CLASSICS (#12)
  4. Father’s Day – CLASSICS (#65)
  5. The End of the World – GREAT (#91)
  6. The Unquiet Dead – GREAT (#121)
  7. Rose – GOOD (#128)
  8. Boom Town – GOOD (#153)
  9. Aliens of London/World War Three – OK (#177)
  10. The Long Game – OK (#204)

9th Doctor TIer List

tenthdoctor

10. The Tenth Doctor (David Tennant) – 2005-2010

  1. Blink – ELITE (#2)
  2. Midnight – ELITE (#5)
  3. The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit – ELITE (#6)
  4. The Waters of Mars – CLASSICS (#19)
  5. The Stolen Earth/Journey’s End – CLASSICS (#20)
  6. Human Nature/The Family of Blood – CLASSICS (#21)
  7. Army of Ghosts/Doomsday – CLASSICS (#30)
  8. Turn Left – CLASSICS (#32)
  9. Utopia/The Sound of Drums/Last of the Time Lords – CLASSICS (#34)
  10. School Reunion – CLASSICS (#39)
  11. Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead – CLASSICS (#40)
  12. Time Crash – CLASSICS
  13. Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel – GREAT (#67)
  14. The Girl in the Fireplace – GREAT (#69)
  15. The Sontaran Stratagem/The Poison Sky – GREAT (#71)
  16. The Christmas Invasion – GREAT (#84)
  17. The Unicorn and the Wasp – GREAT (#87)
  18. The Fires of Pompeii – GREAT (#100)
  19. The End of Time – GREAT (#106)
  20. Planet of the Ood – GREAT (#113)
  21. The Shakespeare Code – GOOD (#125)
  22. Tooth and Claw – GOOD (#126)
  23. Gridlock – GOOD (#155)
  24. Love & Monsters – GOOD (#166)
  25. Partners in Crime – OK (#178)
  26. The Lazarus Experiment – OK (#193)
  27. The Idiot’s Lantern – OK (#205)
  28. Voyage of the Damned – BELOW AVERAGE (#214)
  29. The Runaway Bride – BELOW AVERAGE (#215)
  30. The Infinite Quest – BELOW AVERAGE
  31. The Doctor’s Daughter – BELOW AVERAGE (#220)
  32. Planet of the Dead – BELOW AVERAGE (#227)
  33. 42 – BELOW AVERAGE (#230)
  34. Smith and Jones – BAD (#245)
  35. The Next Doctor – BAD (#256)
  36. New Earth – BAD (#258)
  37. Daleks in Manhattan/Evolution of the Daleks – BAD (#269)
  38. Dreamland – BAD
  39. Fear Her – AWFUL (#282)

my-image (12)

maxresdefault

11. The Eleventh Doctor (Matt Smith) – 2010-2013

  1. The Day of the Doctor – ELITE (#8)
  2. Vincent and the Doctor – CLASSICS (#25)
  3. The Eleventh Hour – CLASSICS (#38)
  4. Cold War – CLASSICS (#43)
  5. The Name of the Doctor – CLASSICS (#44)
  6. The Doctor’s Wife – CLASSICS (#51)
  7. The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon – CLASSICS (#56)
  8. The Bells of Saint John – GREAT (#68)
  9. The Snowmen – GREAT (#75)
  10. Amy’s Choice – GREAT (#77)
  11. The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone – GREAT (#78)
  12. The Angels Take Manhattan – GREAT (#90)
  13. The Lodger – GREAT (#94)
  14. A Good Man Goes to War – GREAT (#104)
  15. The God Complex – GREAT (#109)
  16. The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang – GREAT (#111)
  17. The Girl Who Waited – GREAT (#123)
  18. The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood – GOOD (#124)
  19. The Rebel Flesh/The Almost People – GOOD (#127)
  20. Hide – GOOD (#132)
  21. The Crimson Horror – GOOD (#138)
  22. The Vampires of Venice – GOOD (#144)
  23. Dinosaurs on a Spaceship – GOOD (#152)
  24. A Town Called Mercy – GOOD (#162)
  25. The Beast Below – OK (#184)
  26. The Wedding of River Song – OK (#189)
  27. A Christmas Carol – OK (#212)
  28. The Time of the Doctor – BELOW AVERAGE (#225)
  29. Night Terrors – BELOW AVERAGE (#234)
  30. Victory of the Daleks – BAD (#244)
  31. Nightmare in Silver – BAD (#249)
  32. The Power of Three – BAD (#250)
  33. Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS – BAD (#252)
  34. Closing Time – BAD (#253)
  35. The Rings of Akhaten – BAD (#261)
  36. The Curse of the Black Spot – BAD (#265)
  37. Asylum of the Daleks – BAD (#273)
  38. Let’s Kill Hitler – AWFUL (#286)
  39. The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe – AWFUL (#287)

11th Doctor Tier List

Doctor-Who

12. The Twelfth Doctor (Peter Capaldi) – 2013-2017

  1. Heaven Sent – CLASSICS (#11)
  2. World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls – CLASSICS (#18)
  3. Mummy on the Orient Express – CLASSICS (#42)
  4. The Zygon Invasion/The Zygon Inversion – CLASSICS (#47)
  5. The Magician’s Apprentice/The Witch’s Familiar – CLASSICS (#48)
  6. Dark Water/Death in Heaven – CLASSICS (#49)
  7. Listen – CLASSICS (#60)
  8. Flatline – CLASSICS (#64)
  9. Under the Lake/Before the Flood – GREAT (#73)
  10. Deep Breath – GREAT (#74)
  11. Knock Knock – GREAT (#79)
  12. Into the Dalek – GREAT (#82)
  13. The Pilot – GOOD (#135)
  14. Extremis – GOOD (#147)
  15. Oxygen – GOOD (#148)
  16. The Woman Who Lived – GOOD (#150)
  17. The Husbands of River Song – GOOD (#157)
  18. Thin Ice – GOOD (#161)
  19. Face the Raven – GOOD (#172)
  20. Time Heist – OK (#179)
  21. Twice Upon a Time – OK (#187)
  22. Empress of Mars – OK (#194)
  23. Last Christmas – OK (#197)
  24. The Return of Doctor Mysterio – OK (#201)
  25. The Caretaker – OK (#210)
  26. The Eaters of Light – BELOW AVERAGE (#228)
  27. The Girl Who Died – BELOW AVERAGE (#237)
  28. The Lie of the Land – BELOW AVERAGE (#239)
  29. Robot of Sherwood – BAD (#247)
  30. Kill the Moon – BAD (#251)
  31. Hell Bent – BAD (#263)
  32. The Pyramid at the End of the World – BAD (#271)
  33. Smile – BAD (#274)
  34. In the Forest of the Night – BAD (#276)
  35. Sleep No More – AWFUL (#280)

12th Doctor Tier List

2fnn41uo0wv1000

13. The Thirteenth Doctor (Jodie Whittaker) – 2018-present

  1. Spyfall CLASSICS (#50)
  2. Fugitive of the Judoon CLASSICS (#54)
  3. The Haunting of Villa Diodati – CLASSICS (#58)
  4. Rosa GREAT (#115)
  5. The Woman Who Fell to Earth – GOOD (#130)
  6. Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror – GOOD (#134)
  7. Resolution GOOD (#136)
  8. Kerblam! – GOOD (#143)
  9. The Witchfinders – GOOD (#149)
  10. Arachnids in the UK GOOD (#151)
  11. Can You Hear Me? – GOOD (#171)
  12. Ascension of the Cybermen/The Timeless Children – OK (#190)
  13. Orphan 55 OK (#195)
  14. It Takes You Away – OK (#207)
  15. The Ghost Monument – BELOW AVERAGE (#223)
  16. The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos – BELOW AVERAGE (#240)
  17. Praxeus – BELOW AVERAGE (#242)
  18. Demons of the Punjab – BAD (#268)
  19. The Tsuranga Conundrum – AWFUL (#290)

13th Doctor Tier List

If we tabulate the above Doctor-by-Doctor results, we can see how they compare to one another in terms of my score given to each of their episodes.

ELITE

CLASSICS

GREAT

GOOD

OK

BELOW AVERAGE

BAD

AWFUL

Jo Martin

0

1

0

0

1

0

0

0

William Hartnell

0

4

10

3

5

1

4

2

Patrick Troughton

1

6

2

2

2

4

1

3

Jon Pertwee

0

6

8

3

3

2

2

0

Tom Baker

2

8

5

9

8

2

6

2

Peter Davison

1

2

5

3

1

4

2

2

Colin Baker

0

0

2

1

1

2

0

2

Sylvester McCoy

0

2

1

4

1

1

0

3

Paul McGann

0

1

0

1

0

0

0

0

John Hurt

1

2

0

0

0

0

0

0

Christopher Eccleston

2

2

2

2

2

0

0

0

David Tennant

3

9

8

4

3

6

5

1

Matt Smith

1

6

10

7

3

2

8

2

Peter Capaldi

0

8

4

7

6

3

6

1

Jodie Whittaker

0

3

1

7

3

3

1

1

42160689_2102608159749252_7040489332825653248_o

I genuinely love all of the Doctors in their own way and so it is arguably unfair to rank them because they are all good. For me, each of them brings something different to the role. When I rewatch each of the Doctor’s eras, I can see why every Doctor is someone’s favourite. However, every Doctor Who fan has a favourite Doctor… including me.

Favourite Doctor:

davidtennant-1600x720

David Tennant is still regarded by most fans as the best iteration of the Doctor in the programme’s history. I know that my phenomenally mainstream view does not lessen this fact. However, most people tend to love the Doctor that they grew up with the most. And for that reason, the charismatic Tenth Doctor will always be my favourite. His is the golden era that gripped me as a child and led to my lifelong obsession with Doctor Who. For that, I will always be grateful to him and I can think of no finer and more passionate actor to embody the role of the Doctor.

Before we get onto the rankings of the various TV spin-offs, films and other Doctor Who media, I wish to include a brief discussion of my favourite companion, monsters, Master, seasons and behind-the-scenes writer from the programme’s history.

Favourite Companion:

a1c3ecf94fbad1f93739a0e7ad7a6c8c

Favourite Monsters and Villains Personal (Top 10) Ranking:

dw_monsters-1600x720

  1. Daleks
  2. Cybermen
  3. The Master
  4. Weeping Angels
  5. Davros
  6. Silurians / Sea Devils
  7. Ice Warriors
  8. The Great Intelligence / Yeti
  9. Sontarans
  10. Zygons

Favourite Master:

the-master-roger-delgado

For me, the definitive Master will always be the original, the Machiavellian Roger Delgado. He had a sinister but charming quality that made him the ultimate Moriarty to the Doctor’s Sherlock Holmes. This was the intention of the late Barry Letts and Terrance Dicks, who both masterminded the character behind the scenes back in the early 1970s.

However, it was John Simm who really set the template for how the modern version of the Master should be played, if Michelle Gomez and Sacha Dhawan’s similarly maniacal portrayals are anything to go by. You can even see Simm’s influence in Andrew Scott’s performance as Moriarty in Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat’s hugely popular series Sherlock (2010-2017). Given the early inspiration for the creation of the Master, it seems like this reminiscent performance from Scott may be more than just a coincidence.

nlarfm5wmub31

Favourite Writer:

Russell T Davies

As you have probably ascertained from the above poll results, I regard the period between 2005-2010 to be a truly golden age for Doctor Whowith 2008 being the best overall year for the programme in terms of quality. This is primarily because 2005-2010 was the era of the show that I grew up with as a child, but also because of the huge popularity of the programme and the ensuing spin offs of Doctor Who at the time. Series 1-5 of the new series of Doctor Who, plus Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures, were, generally speaking, better than all of previous and subsequent Doctor Who on television.

In retrospect, it is clear to me that Russell T Davies presided over the best era in Doctor Who‘s entire history. Given the fact that this era of the show is continually held in very high esteem by most newcomers to the programme, I know now that simple childhood nostalgia does not entirely cloud my judgment. The RTD tenure (Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant) was the period in which Doctor Who became a mainstream success, where the general public watched it in numbers almost unseen in the programme’s history. The show was catapulted back into the public consciousness. Many fans today wish that Doctor Who could return to this level of mainstream popularity in the UK.

Although Steven Moffat did keep up the standard (mostly) throughout his time as head writer, I can’t help but feel that he was less capable of structuring the overarching plot of an entire series in comparison to his predecessor Davies. However, many people consider Steven Moffat to be one of Doctor Who’s greatest individual writers. Certainly a lot of his standalone episodes feature very highly in my own list as well as those of most other fans. The 50th Anniversary year of Doctor Who was an extraordinary celebration of a television institution and Steven Moffat should certainly take a lot of credit for this.

If the late, great Robert Holmes and Terrance Dicks were alive to see what their work would inspire in both a young Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat, I’m sure that both of these titans of Doctor Who writing would be very proud indeed.

Comic-Con International 2016 - "Sherlock" Press Room

At this point, I also wish to include a brief personal ranking of every individual season of Doctor Who to date. This ranking roughly correlates with the hierarchy of episodes above.

Individual Seasons Personal Ranking:

Classic Doctor Who (20th Century)

  1. Season 14
  2. Season 12
  3. Season 13
  4. Season 7
  5. Season 10
  6. Season 5
  7. Season 26
  8. Season 25
  9. Season 19
  10. Season 8
  11. Season 9
  12. Season 16
  13. Season 2
  14. Season 22
  15. Season 18
  16. Season 21
  17. Season 3
  18. Season 1
  19. Season 6
  20. Season 4
  21. Season 20
  22. Season 11
  23. Season 15
  24. Season 17
  25. Season 23
  26. Season 24

New Doctor Who (21st Century)

  1. Series 4
  2. Series 1
  3. Series 5
  4. Series 3
  5. Series 2
  6. Series 9
  7. Series 8
  8. Series 7
  9. Series 6
  10. Series 10
  11. Series 12
  12. Series 11

Overall

cwypxaqnh7jbpclrr6xs

  1. New Series 4
  2. New Series 1
  3. New Series 5
  4. New Series 3
  5. New Series 2
  6. Classic Season 14
  7. Classic Season 12
  8. Classic Season 13
  9. Classic Season 7
  10. Classic Season 10
  11. Classic Season 5
  12. Classic Season 26
  13. Classic Season 25
  14. Classic Season 19
  15. Classic Season 8
  16. Classic Season 9
  17. Classic Season 16
  18. New Series 9
  19. Classic Season 2
  20. Classic Season 22
  21. New Series 8
  22. Classic Season 18
  23. Classic Season 21
  24. New Series 7
  25. Classic Season 3
  26. Classic Season 1
  27. Classic Season 6
  28. Classic Season 4
  29. New Series 6
  30. New Series 10
  31. Classic Season 20
  32. Classic Season 11
  33. New Series 12
  34. Classic Season 15
  35. Classic Season 17
  36. Classic Season 23
  37. New Series 11
  38. Classic Season 24

Having now revealed and extensively examined the full ranking results of the past 57 years of Doctor Who, it’s time to examine the Doctor Who spin-offs and other media to see how they stack up.

Films

Personal Ranking of the Peter Cushing films                        ★★★☆☆ 

Rank Story Title Year Foe Category
1. Dr. Who and the Daleks 1965 Daleks GOOD
2. Daleks’ Invasion Earth 2150 A.D. 1966 Daleks GOOD

maxresdefault (1)

TV Spin-Offs

Personal Ranking of episodes from K-9 & COMPANY (1981)           ★★☆☆☆ 

Rank Story Title Series Year Foe Category
1. A Girl’s Best Friend Christmas Special 1981 Hecate Cult BAD

p036967z

Personal Ranking of episodes from TORCHWOOD (2006-2011)        ★★★★★

Rank Story Title Series Year Foe Category
1. Children of Earth: Days One-Five 3 2009 The 456 ELITE
2. Fragments 2 2008 Captain John Hart CLASSICS
3. Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang 2 2008 Captain John Hart CLASSICS
4. Exit Wounds 2 2008 Captain John Hart, Grey CLASSICS
5. Captain Jack Harkness 1 2006 Bilis Manger CLASSICS
6. A Day in the Death 2 2008 CLASSICS
7. Out of Time 1 2006 CLASSICS
8. Adam 2 2008 Adam CLASSICS
9. Everything Changes 1 2006 Weevils CLASSICS
10. Dead Man Walking 2 2008 Death, Weevils CLASSICS
11. Reset 2 2008 The PHARM, Aaron Copley CLASSICS
12. Meat 2 2008 Vic, Dale GREAT
13. To the Last Man 2 2008 GREAT
14. Greeks Bearing Gifts 1 2006 Mary the Arcateenian GREAT
15. From Out of the Rain 2 2008 The Ghost Maker GREAT
16. End of Days 1 2006 Abaddon, Bilis Manger GREAT
17. Ghost Machine 1 2006 Ed Morgan GREAT
18. Adrift 2 2008 GOOD
19. They Keep Killing Suzie 1 2006 Suzie Costello GOOD
20. Combat 1 2006 Mark Lynch, Weevils GOOD
21. Countrycide 1 2006 Cannibal villagers GOOD
22. Something Borrowed 2 2008 Nostrovite GOOD
23. Small Worlds 1 2006 Fairies GOOD
24. Sleeper 2 2008 Sleeper Agents OK
25. Miracle Day (Episodes 1-10) 4 2011 The Families BAD
26. Random Shoes 1 2006 BAD
27. Cyberwoman 1 2006 Lisa the Cyberwoman AWFUL
28. Day One 1 2006 Sex Gas Alien AWFUL

Torchwood-Believe-image-2e7a484

Personal Ranking of episodes from THE SARAH JANE ADVENTURES (2007-2011) ★★★★★

Rank Story Title Series Year Foe Category
1. Death of the Doctor 4 2010 Shansheeth ELITE
2. Whatever Happened to Sarah Jane? 1 2007 Trickster, Graske CLASSICS
3. The Temptation of Sarah-Jane Smith 2 2008 Trickster, Graske CLASSICS
4. Revenge of the Slitheen 1 2007 Slitheen CLASSICS
5. The Curse of Clyde Langer 5 2011 Hetocumtek CLASSICS
6. The Nightmare Man 4 2010 Nightmare Man CLASSICS
7. The Wedding of Sarah-Jane Smith 3 2009 Trickster CLASSICS
8. The Empty Planet 4 2010 CLASSICS
9. The Mark of the Beserker 2 2008 Beserker Pendant GREAT
10. Eye of the Gorgon 1 2007 Gorgon Parasite GREAT
11. The Day of the Clown 2 2008 Oddbod the Clown GREAT
12. Mona Lisa’s Revenge 3 2009 Mona Lisa GREAT
13. The Man Who Never Was 5 2011 John Harrison GREAT
14. Goodbye, Sarah Jane Smith 4 2010 Ruby White GREAT
15. The Last Sontaran 2 2008 Kaag the Sontaran GREAT
16. The Eternity Trap 3 2009 Erasmus Darkening GOOD
17. Enemy of the Bane 2 2008 Mrs Wormwood, Kaag the Sontaran, Bane GOOD
18. The Vault of Secrets 4 2010 Mr Dread GOOD
19. Prisoner of the Judoon 3 2009 Androvax GOOD
20. The Lost Boy 1 2007 Slitheen, Xylok GOOD
21. Secrets of the Stars 2 2008 Ancient Lights GOOD
22. Lost in Time 4 2010 GOOD
23. Invasion of the Bane 1 2007 Mrs Wormwood, Bane GOOD
24. From Raxacoricofallapatorius with Love

Red Nose Day Special

2009 Slitheen GOOD
25. The Gift 3 2009 Slitheen-Blathereen OK
26. Warriors of Kudlak 1 2007 Kudlak BELOW AVERAGE
27. The Mad Woman in the Attic 3 2009 BAD
28. Sky

5

2011 Miss Myers, Metalkind BAD

landscape-1519317374-sarah-jane-adventures

Personal Ranking of episodes from K-9 (2009-10)             ★☆☆☆☆

Rank Story Title Series Year Foe Category
1. Regeneration 1 2009 Jixen GOOD
2. Liberation 1 2010 Jixen, Merons OK
3. The Korven 1 2010 Korven OK
4. Taphony and the Time Loop 1 2010 Taphony BELOW AVERAGE
5. Alien Avatar 1 2010 Drake BELOW AVERAGE
6. Sirens of Ceres 1 2010 Drake BELOW AVERAGE
7. Dream-Eaters 1 2010 Bodach BELOW AVERAGE
8. The Bounty Hunter 1 2010 Ahab, Drake BELOW AVERAGE
9. The Eclipse of the Korven 1 2010 Korven, Thorne, Lomax, Trojan BELOW AVERAGE
10. Curse of Anubis 1 2010 Anubians BELOW AVERAGE
11. Hound of the Korven 1 2010 Thorne BELOW AVERAGE
12. Robot Gladiators 1 2010 Thorne, Lomax, Freddie Maxwell, Pain-Maker BELOW AVERAGE
13. Aeolian 1 2010 Drake BELOW AVERAGE
14. Fear Itself 1 2010 Fear BELOW AVERAGE
15. The Custodians 1 2010 John, Etydion BELOW AVERAGE
16. Angel of the North 1 2010 Korven BELOW AVERAGE
17. Lost Library of Ukko 1 2010 Inspector Thorne BELOW AVERAGE
18. Black Hunger 1 2010 Drake, Thorne, The Hunger BELOW AVERAGE
19. Oroborus 1 2010 Oroborus BAD
20. Jaws of Orthus 1 2010 Drake, Orthus BAD
21. The Cambridge Spy 1 2010 Barker BAD
22. Mutant Copper 1 2010 Thorne, Marcus AWFUL
23. The Last Precinct Thorne AWFUL
24. The Last Oak Tree 1 2010 Drake AWFUL
25. The Fall of the House of Gryffen 1 2010 Gryffen Ghosts AWFUL
26. Mind Snap 1 2010 AWFUL

K9Unit

Personal Ranking of episodes from CLASS (2016)                ★★☆☆☆

Rank Story Title Series Year Foe Category
1. Detained 1 2016 The Prisoner GOOD
2. The Metaphysical Engine, or What Quill Did 1 2016 Quill’s arn GOOD
3. The Lost 1 2016 Shadow Kin, Weeping Angels OK
4. The Coach with the Dragon Tattoo 1 2016 Leaf Dragon OK
5. Nightvisiting 1 2016 Lankin OK
6. For Tonight We Might Die 1 2016 Shadow Kin OK
7. Brave-ish Heart 1 2016 Shadow Kin BELOW AVERAGE
8. Co-Owner of a Lonely Heart 1 2016 Shadow Kin BELOW AVERAGE

ClassBar-1

For New Viewers

Watching Doctor Who alongside its spin-offs as they were originally broadcast is the best order to first view all of the branches of the oak tree that is Doctor Who. To make things easier, I have included a list here of the entirety of the Doctor Who universe on TV (including the spin-offs Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures) in chronological order to show the continuity. This will help new viewers to watch it all in the right order.

Classic Doctor Who: 1963-1989, 1996

William Hartnell

Classic Doctor Who, Season 1       ★★★★☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 2       ★★★★☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 3       ★★★★☆

Patrick Troughton

Classic Doctor Who, Season 4      ★★★★

Classic Doctor Who, Season 5      ★★★★★

Classic Doctor Who, Season 6      ★★★★☆

Jon Pertwee

Classic Doctor Who, Season 7      ★★★★★

Classic Doctor Who, Season 8      ★★★★☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 9      ★★★★☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 10    ★★★★★

Classic Doctor Who, Season 11     ★★★☆☆

Tom Baker

Classic Doctor Who, Season 12    ★★★★★

Classic Doctor Who, Season 13    ★★★★★

Classic Doctor Who, Season 14    ★★★★★

Classic Doctor Who, Season 15    ★★★☆☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 16    ★★★★☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 17    ★★☆☆☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 18    ★★★★☆

K-9 & Company: A Girl’s Best Friend  ★★☆☆☆

Peter Davison

Classic Doctor Who, Season 19    ★★★★☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 20    ★★★☆☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 21    ★★★★☆

Colin Baker

Classic Doctor Who, Season 22    ★★★☆☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 23    ★★☆☆☆

Sylvester McCoy

Classic Doctor Who, Season 24    ★☆☆☆☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 25    ★★★★☆

Classic Doctor Who, Season 26     ★★★★★

Paul McGann

The 1996 TV Movie    ★★★☆☆

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ObftWPbUPvs&feature=emb_title

New Doctor Who: 2005-present

Christopher Eccleston

New Doctor Who, Series 1    ★★★★★

David Tennant

New Doctor Who, Series 2    ★★★★★

Torchwood, Series 1    ★★★★☆

The Sarah Jane Adventures: Invasion of the Bane   ★★★★☆

New Doctor Who, Series 3    ★★★★★

The Sarah Jane Adventures, Series 1    ★★★★★

Torchwood, Series 2    ★★★★★

New Doctor Who, Series 4    ★★★★★

The Sarah Jane Adventures, Series 2    ★★★★★

New Doctor Who: The Next Doctor, Planet of the Dead    ★★★☆☆

Torchwood, Series 3: Children of Earth  ★★★★★

The Sarah Jane Adventures, Series 3   ★★★★☆

K-9, Series 1    ★☆☆☆☆

New Doctor Who: The Waters of Mars, Dreamland, The End of Time    ★★★★★

Matt Smith

New Doctor Who, Series 5    ★★★★★

The Sarah Jane Adventures, Series 4    ★★★★★

New Doctor Who, Series 6    ★★★☆☆

Torchwood, Series 4: Miracle Day    ★★☆☆☆

The Sarah Jane Adventures, Series 5  ★★★★☆

New Doctor Who, Series 7    ★★★☆☆

  • John Hurt

New Doctor Who, 50th Anniversary Special: The Day of the Doctor    ★★★★★

New Doctor Who: The Time of the Doctor   ★★☆☆☆

Peter Capaldi

New Doctor Who, Series 8   ★★★★☆

New Doctor Who, Series 9  ★★★★☆

Class, Series 1   ★★☆☆☆

New Doctor Who, Series 10  ★★★☆☆

Jodie Whittaker

New Doctor Who, Series 11  ★★☆☆☆

  • Jo Martin

New Doctor Who, Series 12   ★★★☆☆

Where is the best place to start watching Doctor Who?

If you wish to watch Doctor Who in the same way as any other TV show, i.e. start at the beginning and work your way through, then that is a perfectly reasonable method. Most episodes of Doctor Who are relatively self-contained stories, meaning a new viewer can start basically at any point in the series history. However, there are (uniquely for such a long-running television programme) multiple, ideal jumping-on points where you can start watching Doctor Who and just continue in broadcast order. Here are a few of them:

CLASSIC DOCTOR WHO

An Unearthly Child (1963) – SEASON 1

The Power of the Daleks (1966) – SEASON 4

The Tomb of the Cybermen (1967) – SEASON 5

Spearhead from Space (1970) – SEASON 7

The Three Doctors (1972-3) – SEASON 10

The Time Warrior (1973-4) – SEASON 11

Robot (1974-5) – SEASON 12

The Deadly Assassin (1976) – SEASON 14

The Leisure Hive (1980) – SEASON 18

The Keeper of Traken (1981) – SEASON 18

The Five Doctors (1983) – SEASON 20

Attack of the Cybermen (1985) – SEASON 22

Remembrance of the Daleks (1988) – SEASON 25

NEW DOCTOR WHO

Rose (2005) – SERIES 1

Blink (2007) – SERIES 3 

The Eleventh Hour (2010) – SERIES 5

The Snowmen (2012) – SERIES 7

Deep Breath (2014) – SERIES 8

The Pilot (2017) – SERIES 10

The Woman Who Fell to Earth (2018) – SERIES 11

Unknown's avatar

About Chris Olsen's TARDIS

I am an aspiring television producer, screenwriter and showrunner. I became a childhood fan of the popular BBC TV series Doctor Who at the age of 10, when my parents introduced me to the show upon its return in 2005. I am interested in all things sci-fi, fantasy and geeky, but Doctor Who takes the crown above all else. This website will detail my reviews of various episodes of Doctor Who from throughout its 60-year history. It will also contain content relating to other franchises that I grew up with as a kid, such as Star Wars and Harry Potter.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The Best Doctor Who Episode of All Time (2020)

  1. Pingback: Doctor Who Missing 1960s Episodes Animation Schedule | Christopher Olsen Reviews

  2. Tony Pazak's avatar Tony Pazak says:

    Excellent list. Thanks for the hard work

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Doctor Who Missing 1960s Episodes Animation Schedule | Christopher Olsen

  4. Pingback: Doctor Who Missing 1960s Episodes Animation Schedule | Chris Olsen Reviews

Comments are closed.